Menu of Anthony's Pizza & Pasta in West Islip, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta, located on 791 Udall Rd in West Islip, NY, is a beacon of authentic New York-style pizza and Italian comfort food. This unpretentious spot boasts a menu anchored by classics like their Cheese Pizza and Pepperoni Pizza Pops, but their real standout items are the hearty Chicken Cutlet Hero and the mouthwatering Stromboli.

The Cheese Pizza here captures that perfect balance of a thin, flavorful crust topped with a generous layer of mozzarella that melts into golden bliss. The Pepperoni Pizza Pops are a clever twist—bite-sized, crispy on the outside, and bursting with a rich pepperoni and cheese blend inside. It’s no wonder these are crowd favorites.

Moving beyond pizza, the Chicken Cutlet Hero is a star in its own right. Tender, breaded chicken cutlets layered with fresh tomato sauce and melted mozzarella create a comforting, robust sandwich experience. Similarly, the Stromboli here is baked to a golden perfection, stuffed generously with Italian sausage, peppers, and onions, infusing each bite with authentic savory flavors.

Anthony’s also shines in their all-day rolls category, particularly the Chicken Rolls and Sausage, Peppers, & Onions rolls. Vicky Cianci’s praise of the rolls’ generous size and deeply flavorful sauce rings true. The rolls come wrapped in soft, freshly baked pizza dough, delivering satisfaction in both portion and taste.

For those who love Italian heroes, their Hot Italian Heroes menu covers a variety of hearty options like Sausage & Peppers, Meatball, and an impressive Shrimp hero, with choices of plain or parmesan style. These sandwiches are crafted with fresh ingredients and bold flavors, offering an authentic New York deli vibe.

The Cold Antipasto salad is another highlight, especially after 4 PM. It combines imported meats, marinated vegetables, and provolone cheese with mixed greens—perfect for balancing out the richness of other dishes.

What truly elevates Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta is the palpable sense of tradition and care evident in every dish. Customer reviews echo a consistent theme: large portions, crispy and flavorful dough, and a menu that respects its roots without pretension. CarrieAnn’s reflection on the warm, family-like hospitality sets the tone for the entire dining experience—it feels genuine and welcoming, the kind of place where you want to linger over every bite.

Cleanliness and consistency are also valued here, as Jill Fromann notes, ensuring that the food not only tastes great but is served in an inviting environment. Owner Anthony Musumeci’s direct approach to feedback highlights transparency and pride in his establishment, reinforcing the authenticity behind the name.

Whether you are stopping by for a classic slice, indulging in one of their signature heroes, or savoring a specialty roll, Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta delivers a powerful punch of New York flavor that is both satisfying and true to its heritage. This is not just a meal; it’s a nostalgic taste journey crafted with confidence and heart.